Over the Earth’s evolutionary history, the style of plate subduction has evolved through time due to the secular cooling of the mantle. While continuous subduction is a typical feature of modern plate tectonics, a stagnant-lid tectonic regime with localized episodic subduction likely characterized the early Earth. The timing of the transition between these two subduction styles bears important insights into Earth’s cooling history. Here we apply a statistical analysis to a large geochemical dataset of mafic rocks spanning the last 3.5 Ga, which shows an increasing magnitude of alkali basaltic magmatism beginning at ca. 2.1 Ga. We propose that the rapid rise of continental alkali basalts correlates with an abruptly decreasing degree of mantle melting resulting from the enhanced cooling of the mantle at ca. 2.1 Ga. This might be a consequence of the initiation of continuous subduction, which recycled increasing volumes of cold oceanic crust into the mantle.